Decisions - BC Forest Appeals Commission

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Forest Practices Board v. Government of British Columbia

Husby Group of Companies, Permit Holder

Application for change in venue

REQUEST GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000for009a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 20, 2001

Decision Number:
2000-FOR-009(a)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Laurie Parker v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000fa010.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 26, 2001

Decision Number:
2000-FA-010

Act:

Forest Act
Rudy and Celia Harfman v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for006.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 1, 2001

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-006

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Gloria O’Brien v. Government of British Columbia

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for07.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 14, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-007

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Forest Practices Board v. Government of British Columbia; Crestbrook Forest Industries, Ltd.

Consent order

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000for005.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 23, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FOR-005

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000fa004.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 28, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FA-004

Act:

Forest Act
Robin Brekkas v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000fa001.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 18, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FA-001

Act:

Forest Act
Calvin Carter v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000fa002.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 18, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FA-002

Act:

Forest Act
Slocan Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for08.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 14, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-008

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Alan Kendall v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000for002.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 14, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FOR-002

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/2000fa003.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 29, 2000

Decision Number:
2000-FA-003

Act:

Forest Act
Weyerhaeuser Company Limited v. Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999fab01.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 23, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FAB-001

Act:

Forest Act
Western Forest Products Ltd. v. Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999fab03.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 19, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FAB-003

Act:

Forest Act
Forest Practices Board v. Government of British Columbia

Takla Development Corporation Ltd., Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for05.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 10, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-005

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Forest Practices Board v. Government of British Columbia

Gloria O’Brien, Third Party

Final decision

COMMISSION REVERSES ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW DECISION AND CONFIRMS ISSUANCE

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for02.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 8, 2000

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-002

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Forest Practices Board v. Pas Lumber Co. Ltd. and Government of British Columbia

Consent order

PENALTIES VARIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999for04.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 15, 1999

Decision Number:
1999-FOR-04

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Guy Montgomery Jr. and Eagle Crest Properties Ltd. v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL UPHELD IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998fab05.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 27, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FAB-05

Act:

Forest Act
Laurie Parker and Family Cattle Co. Ltd. v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1999Fab02.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 19, 1999

Decision Number:
1999-FAB-02

Act:

Forest Act
Rudolph and Celia Harfman v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED, PENALTY IS REINSTATED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for10.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 20, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-10

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Woodland Lumber Ltd. v. Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Ministry of Forests

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998fab06.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 16, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FAB-06

Act:

Forest Act
Denis Hurtubise v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998fab09.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 28, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FAB-09

Act:

Forest Act
Riverside Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for07.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 31, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-07

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for09.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 5, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-09

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Slocan Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Majority decision of panel members

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for23.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 20, 1999

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-23

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Robert E. Stevens and Linda A. Krofta v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for05.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 15, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-05

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Alan R. Luoma v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

PANEL UPHOLDS THE REVIEW PANEL DECISION, VARIES THE PENALTIES IMPOSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for06_1998fab04.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 12, 1999

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-06

1998-FAB-04

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Finlay Forest Industries Inc. v. Ministry of Forests

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997fab04.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 7, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FAB-04

Act:

Forest Act
Slocan Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for24.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 2, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-24

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Safe Enterprises D.L.S. Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for04.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 6, 1998

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-04

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Slocan Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for22.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 29, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-22

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
MacMillan Bloedel Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED ON BASIS OF CORRECTION OF STUMPAGE ADVISORY NOTICE AND NOT A REAPPRAISAL

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997fab05.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 23, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FAB-05

Act:

Forest Act
Aspen Planers Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for01.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 14, 1998

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-01

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Slocan Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998for02.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 1, 1998

Decision Number:
1998-FOR-02

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
J.S. Jones Holdings Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for32.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 25, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-32

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Edward Yaremchuk v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for31.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 4, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-31

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
William Hollis v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for13.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 31, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-13

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Fab-Co Forest Products (1989) Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for33.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 27, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-33

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Frank McIntyre v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for18.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 17, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-18

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Bernard M. Angel and Ann Angel v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for36.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 13, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-36

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Western Forest Products Limited; MacMillan Bloedel Limited; Canadian Forest Products Limited; District of Mission; International Forest Products Limited; Richmond Plywood Corporation Limited v. Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Ministry of Forests

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997fab08.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 17, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FAB-08

Act:

Forest Act
Dean Foisy v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

DECISION OF REVIEW PANEL IS APPROPRIATE AND PENALTY IS REINSTATED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for35.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 30, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-35

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Kenneth Robert Wapple v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL UPHELD IN PART, TOTAL PENALTY AND CHARGES REVISED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998fab02.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 24, 1998

Decision Number:
1998-FAB-02

Act:

Forest Act
Forest Practices Board v. Government of British Columbia

MacMillan Bloedel Limited, Third Party Sierra Club of British Columbia, Intervenor

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/96-04b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 11, 1998

Decision Number:
96/04(b)

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Paul Anthony Long v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1998fab01.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 27, 1998

Decision Number:
1998-FAB-01

Act:

Forest Act
Peter Grundmann v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART, PENALTY REDUCED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for26.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 21, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-26

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Cecil Alexander Pangburn v. Government of British Columbia

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for34.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 24, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-34

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

COMMISSION RULES AGAINST A REFERRAL BACK TO THE DISTRICT MANAGER FOR A REDETERMINATION ON ISSUES

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for17.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 23, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-017

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Canadian Forest Products Ltd. v. Government of British Columbia

Forest Practices Board, Third Party

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997for30.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 24, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FOR-30

Act:

Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act
Biport Forest Products Ltd. v. Ministry of Forests

Consent order

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997fab09.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 11, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FAB-09

Act:

Forest Act
TimberWest Forest Limited v. The Province of British Columbia (Ministry of Forests)

Final decision

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfac.ca/app/uploads/sites/837/2020/06/1997fab07.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 4, 1998

Decision Number:
1997-FAB-07

Act:

Forest Act

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Acts